Last I rode the old S2 (5 years ago?) I was having trouble with missed shifts into 2nd ....especially after a hard run, coming to a stop and then taking off again....(it never jumped out once in) But you know, 1st......and then the shift to 2nd when the selector says, "nah, I prefer neutral right now"..and the poor sap behind me gets fogged and I try hopelessly to click back down and ride away with some dignity.
I have the top gear case upside down on the bench, with everything in there...looking at how it shifts, paying close attention to the shift into 2nd. I know that it would certainly behave differently while running...however, if I manually align all the dogs with the holes they need to go into, then you can see them working...or not....
For example, as I line things up for the shift into 1st, its really nice, clockwork. back and forth .
Now bear with my insane explanation:
Trying 2nd is another story. As it sets, it will not go. As you shift into 2nd, 2 things need to happen.
For 1, the gear that engages for 1st comes out to its neutral postion-and then just a bit more
Secondly, the other fork moves the gear on the other end in to engage 2nd.
I isolated the problem by taking the fork pins out one by one. The gear that meshes on shifting into 2nd slides and engages back and forth quite well with the other fork pin absent.
The gear that comes out of 1st, and then moves over a tad more as 2nd is selected? No...when I have just that fork pin in it still does not work.
There is a channel cut into the shaft itself, and there is a pin in that gear that rides in that channel---it limits the gear's travel in the direction it needs to go for the shift into 2nd to happen. THAT is whats holding it up. The shift fork would like to move it a bit more, but it cant.
I occurs to me that perhaps the output shaft is out of alignment so to speak--if the shaft sat a bit more to the right as Im looking at it, the shift into 2nd would probably go....I checked the parts diagrams and I dont see what would nessecarily keep that shaft in position....The bearing's clip that sits in the slot on the sprocket side is in position, as is the little nub on the bushing on the other end. There is no play back and forth on the output shaft either, so shimming doesnt seem to be an option.
If I tapped the shaft over would it move? what would keep it from moving later if thats the case? I could possibly mill out that slot on the shaft a sixteenth or so, but ehhhhh....
What am I missing here? Obviously, the symptom Im seeing doesnt quite match what I saw on the road, but it seems to point to some trouble, I certainly wouldnt put it back together with it acting like that!!
Any input would be greatly appreciated!!!!
